Game shooting can help address nature agencies’ failings

The Office for Environmental Protection says Defra and Natural England are failing in their legal duties to protect wild birds. Supporting game shooting should be part of the response, argues Alex Murray.

UK wild bird populations are at their lowest recorded level, with 45 per cent of 132 native breeding species in decline over a five-year period.

As a result, the Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has issued decision notices that Defra and Natural England are failing to fulfil important legal responsibilities for the protection and recovery of wild birds. The findings highlight wider and long-standing shortcomings in the implementation of environmental legislation and the effectiveness of the protected site system.

Protected sites need active management

Designating protected sites is only part of the solution. These sites must be properly monitored, resourced and actively managed if they are to deliver the conservation outcomes for which they were established. The OEP’s findings reinforce concerns that insufficient monitoring, investment, management advice and engagement with landowners and occupiers are undermining their effectiveness.

Shooting is already delivering for nature

Across the country, people involved in shooting are already making a substantial contribution to nature conservation. In the uplands, gamekeepers and grouse moor managers undertake habitat management and predator control that can support vulnerable species, including curlew and lapwing. Similar work takes place across other landscapes, often funded and delivered by shooting estates and their associated land managers.

New research has found that UK farmland bird indicator species and other bird groups are more likely to be found on farms with shoots than on otherwise similar farms.

Effective nature recovery requires properly functioning protected-site systems and meaningful collaboration with the people who manage these landscapes. Gamekeepers, land managers and those involved in shooting are part of that solution and should be recognised as partners in delivering conservation outcomes.

BASC has detailed all the research in its response to Defra’s recent game shooting call for evidence. That research is reinforced by 26,000 people sharing first-hand accounts of shooting’s personal and environmental benefits, its relationship with farming and the spending it generates with local businesses.

What needs to change

Defra must listen to the evidence and drop the threat of a ‘stealth ban’ on game shooting from its land-use framework.

Natural England needs to modify the licensing of gamebird releasing in and around Special Protection Areas (SPAs) and its recent partial change in approach is a welcome start.

Rather than more costly and time-consuming consultations and tinkering with designations, what is needed is government support for sustainably run game shoots as partners in nature recovery, within and around SPAs and across the wider countryside.

The OEP’s findings should be a turning point. Defra and Natural England must recognise that game shooting is a solution that needs supporting, not a problem that needs solving.

Share

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.